When you move to a city for college or a first job, the question comes up within a week: stay in a PG, or find two or three people and rent a flat together? Both work for a lot of people. The right answer depends less on the rent and more on how you live. This guide lays out the differences honestly, so you can choose once and not move twice.
What you are actually comparing
A PG is a service. You pay one amount, and someone else handles the building, the food, the cleaning, the electricity bill and the repairs. A flat is a household. You pay rent to a landlord, and you and your flatmates handle everything else. Most of the differences below follow from that.
Cost
People often assume a flat is cheaper. Sometimes it is, but compare like with like. A PG's rent usually includes food, electricity up to some limit, WiFi, cleaning and furniture. For a flat, add up:
- Your share of the rent.
- Your share of electricity, water, gas and WiFi.
- Food: a cook, a tiffin service, or groceries and your own time.
- A maid for cleaning and utensils.
- Furniture and kitchen things, unless the flat is furnished.
- Brokerage, if you found the flat through a broker.
- A deposit that is usually larger than a PG's.
Write both totals per month for your city before deciding. For many students the totals end up close, and the decision is made by the other points below.
Food
In a PG, food is decided for you. That is a relief in the first months and can become tiring later, especially if the menu repeats or the timings do not match your day. In a flat you choose: cook, hire a cook, or order a tiffin service. That freedom costs effort, and someone has to organise it.
Freedom and rules
A PG has house rules: a gate time, rules on guests, sometimes on cooking or noise. Some people find these reassuring, especially in a new city. A flat has the rules you and your flatmates agree on, plus whatever the landlord and the society allow. If you work late shifts, keep irregular hours or like having friends over, a flat usually fits better.
Effort
This is the point people underestimate. In a flat, someone has to pay the bills on time, call the plumber, deal with the landlord, find a new flatmate when one leaves, and settle who owes what. If one flatmate leaves suddenly, the rest often have to cover the rent. In a PG none of this is your problem.
Deposits and leaving
PG deposits are usually smaller and the notice period is usually shorter, often a month. A flat is normally rented on a longer agreement with a larger deposit, and leaving early can mean losing part of it. If you are not sure how long you will stay in the city, a PG keeps you flexible. Read our guide to the deposit and rent agreement before signing either.
Privacy and space
A single room in a PG gives privacy at a higher price. Shared rooms are cheaper but you live closely with people you did not choose. In a flat you usually get your own room, a kitchen and a common area, and you choose your flatmates.
Who each one suits
A PG usually suits you if:
- You are new to the city and do not know people yet.
- You want food and cleaning handled.
- You are not sure how long you will stay.
- You would rather not deal with bills, repairs or a landlord.
A shared flat usually suits you if:
- You already have two or three people you trust to live with.
- You want your own room, a kitchen and control over food.
- You keep irregular hours or want fewer rules.
- You plan to stay for a year or more.
A common path
Many people start in a PG for the first few months, learn the city, make friends, and then move to a flat with people they met. That path avoids the two most common mistakes: signing a long flat agreement in a city you do not know yet, and staying years in a PG that stopped suiting you long ago.
Before you decide
- Write the full monthly cost of both, including food and bills.
- Decide how long you are likely to stay.
- Be honest about whether you want to run a household.
- If you choose a PG, use our checklist for visiting a PG.
- If you choose a flat, agree in writing with your flatmates who pays what and what happens if someone leaves.
You can browse PGs with free seats near you on Ondrilla, and if you choose a flat, find a tiffin service nearby and second hand furniture on the Marketplace.
Looking for a place? Compare PGs and tiffin services near you on Ondrilla, with photos, prices, free seats and house rules, and chat with owners in the app.
More guides
- How to Check a PG Before You PayWhat to look at, what to ask, and what to settle before any money changes hands.
- PG Deposit and Rent Agreement: How to Get Your Money BackMost deposit fights start with something that was never written down. Here is what to write down.
- Safety Checklist for a Girls' PGSafety is not one feature on a brochure. It is a set of small things you can check on a single visit.
- How to Choose a Tiffin ServiceThe best tiffin is the one you still look forward to in the third week. Here is how to find it.